Is it Too Late for the Beverage Industry to Save Soda?

What we can learn by analyzing consumer conversations about soda, health and the Dr.Pepper-Keurig merger

Keurig wants to serve more than just single-serve K-cups to its consumers. The coffee giant Keurig Green Mountain acquired Dr Pepper Snapple to satisfy consumers’ thirst throughout the day — be it for coffee, soda, juice or water.

Most Americans consume two-three cups of coffee every day but that’s still not enough time spent with consumers, according to Keurig Green Mountain. So with this new alliance, the merged entity Keurig Dr Pepper wants to “provide the highest-quality hot and cold beverages to satisfy every consumer throughout the day.”

But there may be a fly in the carbonated ointment — consumers have been shying away from soda for several years.

In 2016, American soda consumption dropped by 1.2 percent, falling for 12th year in a row, thanks to consumers jettisoning canisters, perhaps for more coffee. As consumers opt for more healthy food choices, soda makers like Dr Pepper Snapple are on the spot to think out of the can and forge strategic partnerships to stay relevant.

In this post we analyze social media conversations about soda to make sense of the $18.7 billion merger and better understand:

  • Declining soda consumption
  • Coffee’s strong brew
  • Combined forces of coffee and soda

No soda, no pop

As consumers become more conscious of how and what they consume, their health choices influence purchasing decisions. Sales of carbonated drinks hitting a 31-year low in 2016 is an aftereffect of consumers moving healthier beverages over soda.

When we analyzed social media conversations around non-alcoholic beverages like coffee, tea, milk, juice and soda in the past seven years to identify reasons that drive consumption of these beverages, we identified that the conversation centers around three main factors: ingredients, health, and consumer preferences.

Coffee emerged as the most-discussed beverage, with 30 percent share of voice. Soda and milk had roughly the same share of voice, with 22 and 21 percent respectively. Tea and juice, on the other hand, made up about 14 and 13 percent respectively.

When we further broke down the patterns of discussion around ingredients, health consciousness, and consumer preferences, ingredients emerged as the most discussed topic, thanks to the ongoing social dialogue on healthy consumption.

The ingredient discussion reinforces that people check labels before buying a product, which can dissuade someone from making a purchase. Ingredients that most deter consumers are: additives, aspartame, high fructose corn syrup and hormones. Aspartame is most discussed with soda. Another culprit is high fructose corn syrup found in soda and juice. Once  considered a healthier alternative to soda, juice has now become similarly shunned due to its high sugar content.

Qualifying this discussion with consumer sentiment paints a clearer picture.

When we analyzed the conversations on social to glean specific sentiment associated with these ingredients, we found that, unsurprisingly, most were negative. Aspartame topped the list as people called it a cancer-causing substance which also induces mood swings. High fructose corn syrup, a cheaper alternative to sugar, also is discussed negatively for its association with diabetes.

The declining soda consumption likely prodded Dr Pepper Snapple to look for greener pastures. Keeping with consumer trends, the company paid $1.7 billion to buy Bai brands, that’s popular for making drinks with plant-based ingredients with antioxidants and without artificial sweeteners. With Bai, the Dr Pepper Snapple stable includes non-carbonated drinks like Deja Blue water, Snapple Iced tea, Mott’s apple juice, Nantucket juices and chocolate drink Yoohoo.

If consumers are canning soda, what are they drinking?

Coffee’s strong brew

As noted earlier, coffee is the most-discussed beverage occupying 30 percent share of voice in the conversation about beverages. Not only is it the most discussed beverage, it’s also one that is talked about more positively.

Coffee consumption among Americans has also been on the rise. According to the National Coffee Association, In 2010, only 1 in 10 coffee-drinkers had a cup at lunch. That figure had risen to 1 in 4 by 2016. And between 2008 and 2016, past-day consumption of gourmet coffee beverages rose from 13% to 36% among 18-24 year olds, and from 19% to 41% for those 25-39.

Digging deeper into coffee preferences aside from flavors, consumers also talk about the types of coffee they want to purchase or drink. Specialty coffee, defined as coffee produced in microclimates, is a coffee trend that has held steady throughout the years.

The concurrent trends of falling soda sales and rising coffee consumption has left soda-makers in the lurch while opening a field of opportunities for new caffeinated drinks.

“We’re seeing these coffee drinks now that actually resemble soda…It’s a way to get into the segment, because coffee is natural and healthy and tracks with consumer trends,” James Watson, a Rabobank senior beverage analyst told the Washington Post. For instance, Stumptown Coffee Roasters released a “Sparkling Cold Brew” last year in aluminum cans, which it promoted as a summer “road soda.”

Keurig Dr Pepper..an interesting cocktail?

Analysts have spilled a lot of ink explaining the relative benefits for both companies. On social, the audience rejoiced at the news and treated the merger as if it was inevitable.

Conclusion

The decision to acquire and merge with a company is one that involves rigorous and meticulous vetting the market, the risks, and rewards. As social media vies to be a credible archive of consumer feedback and brand perception, it plays a critical role in market research. In the case of Keurig and Dr Pepper, consumer conversations provided enough evidence to gauge the success of the deal. Evolving consumer preferences direct the market and if brands are listening, there is a lot of hay to be made while the sun shines.

Read the full report on the beverage industry here:

Request a Demo

Ready to transform your business?

Get a walkthrough of Crimson Hexagon and learn how consumer insights can help you make better business decisions.